Tates Ice Cream's Facebook Page

Homemade Flavors

Tates Old Fashioned Ice Cream Flavor List

We offer 32 fresh flavors daily. Some are seasonal, but worth waiting for!

 COMING SOON:  STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE, GRAHAM CRACKER, AND WHITE CHOCOLATE RASPBERRY TRUFFLE!Smile 

  • Banana ~ made with fresh banana puree.
  • Birthday Cake ~ yummy, with confetti sprinkles.
  • Black Cherry ~ sweet black cherry ice cream with big, juicy black cherries throughout.
  • Bubble Gum ~ always a kid’s favorite.
  • Blueberry Hill ~ a summer favorite, thick blueberry swirl in vanilla ice cream.
  • Butter Pecan ~ butter roasted and salted pecans make this special.
  • Caramel Java Express ~ a strong coffee ice cream with caramel fudge swirl and cappuccino chips.
  • Chocolate ~ simple and delicious.
  • Chocolate Chip
  • Chocolate Chip Mint
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter ~ a thick and nutty peanut butter rippled through chocolate ice cream.
  • Cinnamon ~ Unique to Tate’s! Folks come from all over to get this delicious flavor.
  • Coconut ~ nothing artificial here, made with the real thing!
  • Coffee
  • Cookie Dough ~ always the crowd pleaser.
  • Cotton Candy ~ tastes just like the carnival treat! (Available in June/July only)
  • Dreamsicle ~ a combo of vanilla and orange sherbet.
  • Frandango ~ chocolate ice cream infused with peppermint extract. A cool, delicious sensation on the tongue!
  • Fudgie Brownie ~ chocolate brownie batter with gooey chocolate brownies and a fudge ripple. No need to say more!
  • Fudge Ripple ~ straight from days gone by.
  • German Chocolate Cake ~ our secret chocolate coconut ice cream with caramel and pecans.
  • Heath Bar Crunch ~ Coffee ice cream with Heath™ bar pieces. Too good!
  • Irish Mocha Chip ~ a customer favorite. Coffee and chocolate ice cream infused with rum and chocolate chips.
  • Mango ~ made fresh with real mango puree
  • Maple Walnut ~ an old time favorite. A taste of Vermont in the Midwest!
  • Mint Meltaway ~ a dual combination of chocolate and mint ice creams.
  • New York Cherry ~ a traditional favorite, made with sweet maraschino cherries
  • Oreo Smash ~ lots of Oreos™ in this!
  • Pecan Praline ~ thick caramel fudge and pralines in vanilla ice cream.
  • Peppermint ~ so good, with bits of crunchy peppermint candy.
  • Pistachio Almond ~ ours is some of the best around!
  • Pumpkin ~ a seasonal favorite, like pumpkin pie.  Available in September
  • Raspberry Fudge Chunk ~ fresh raspberry ice cream swirled with raspberry ripple and fudge chunks.
  • Rum Raisin ~ an autumn favorite. Folks line up for this one!  Available in August
  • Strawberry
  • Train Tracks ~ vanilla ice cream swirled with thick fudge sauce and peanut butter cups.
  • Triple Chocolate ~ chocolate ice cream, chocolate fudge ripple and chocolate chips. For the serious chocolate lover!
  • Vanilla ~ we use real Madagascar vanilla to make this simply delicious!

Sherbets

Our unique recipe makes these flavors simple and refreshing!

  • Lemon
  • Rasberry-Lemonade
  • Orange
  • Lime
flavors